Effects and Comprehensive Evaluation of Different Plant Regulators on Growth of Sugar Beets

doi:10.15933/j.cnki.1004-3268.2025.03.005

Abstract

Abstract: To identify suitable growth regulators for sugar beets under drip irrigation in Xinjiang and improve the sugar beets yield，the effects of different plant growth regulators on agronomic traits，photosynthetic characteristics，yield of sugar beets were investigated. At 50，70，and 90 days after the emergence of sugar beets，four plant growth regulators DPC，CCC，S3307 and ETH，were sprayed three times on the sugar beets，with water as the control（CK），in 2021 and 2022.The results showed that plant growth regulators could effectively reduce plant height，increase photosynthetic pigment content in sugar beet leaves by 7.38%—16.81% and the net photosynthetic rate by 0.54%—21.54%.The four treatments could increase the yield of sugar beet by 5.97%，12.91%，2.84%，14.20% in 2021，and 10.46%，13.08%，8.39%，18.17% in 2022，respectively，compared with CK. The sugar production of the four regulator treatments was increased by 4.56%，10.90%，6.87%，10.35% in 2021，and 8.34%，11.87%，9.44%，0.43% in 2022.By combining PCA（principal component analysis）and entropy weighted TOPSIS comprehensive evaluation，the impact level of the four growth regulators on sugar beets showed CCC>ETH>DPC>S3307>CK.Overall，CCC was the best regulator in regulating the growth，yield，and quality of sugar beets.

Key words: Sugar beets, Plant growth regulator, Growth and development, Yield, Comprehensive evaluation

摘要： 为筛选适宜新疆滴灌条件下提高甜菜产量的生长调节剂，在2021、2022 年分别采用缩节胺（DPC）、矮壮素（CCC）、烯效唑（S3307）、乙烯利（ETH）4种植物生长调节剂在甜菜出苗后50、70、90 d进行3次喷施，同时以喷施清水为对照（CK），探究不同植物生长调节剂对甜菜生长、光合特性及产量的影响。结果表明，喷施植物生长调节剂能够明显降低甜菜株高，甜菜叶片光合色素含量较CK提高7.38%~16.81%，净光合速率较CK提高0.54%~21.54%，甜菜叶片光合物质生产能力得到了有效改善。2021年DPC、CCC、S3307、ETH 处理较CK 分别增产5.97%、12.91%、2.84% 和14.20%，产糖量较CK 分别提高4.56%、10.90%、6.87%和10.35%；2022年较CK分别增产10.46%、13.08%、8.39%和18.17%，产糖量较CK分别提高8.34%、11.87%、9.44%和0.43%。主成分分析和熵权TOPSIS综合评价表明，各生长调节剂对甜菜的效应大小依次为CCC>ETH>DPC>S3307>CK，矮壮素对甜菜生长发育及产量的调控效果最好。

关键词: 甜菜, 生长调节剂, 生长发育, 产量, 综合评价

CLC Number:

S566.3

YUAN Tuantuan, LIU Changbing, BEN Qiuping, DING Zhaofei, WANG Kaiyong, FAN Hua, LI Weinong, LI Zhiqiang. Effects and Comprehensive Evaluation of Different Plant Regulators on Growth of Sugar Beets[J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(3): 40-49.

袁团团, 刘长兵, 本秋平, 丁兆斐, 王开勇, 樊华, 李蔚农, 李志强. 不同生长调节剂对甜菜生长发育的影响及其综合评价[J]. 河南农业科学, 2025, 54(3): 40-49.

Figures/Tables 10

References

［1］SUBRAHMANYESWARI T，GANTAIT S.Advancements and prospectives of sugar beet（Beta vulgaris L.）biotechnology［J］.Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology，2022，106（22）：7417⁃7430.

［2］田露，苏文斌，郭晓霞，等.氮肥基追比例对苏打盐碱土甜菜光合效率及糖产量的调控［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2023，29（7）：1352⁃1366.

TIAN L，SU W B，GUO X X，et al.Optimum basal and topdressing ratios of nitrogen fertilizer for high photosynthetic efficiency and sugar yield of sugar beet in soda alkali⁃saline farmland［J］.Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2023，29（7）：1352⁃1366.

［3］陈艺文，李用财，余凌羿，等.中国三大主产区甜菜糖业发展分析［J］.中国糖料，2017，39（4）：74⁃76.

CHEN Y W，LI Y C，YU L Y，et al.Analysis on the development of beet sugar industry in three main producing areas of China［J］.Sugar Crops of China，2017，39（4）：74⁃76.

［4］卢秉福，吴遂，刘晓雪，等.内蒙古甜菜制糖产业发展分析［J］.中国糖料，2023，45（2）：82⁃90.

LU B F，WU S，LIU X X，et al.Analysis on the development of sugar beet industry in Inner Mongolia［J］.Sugar Crops of China，2023，45（2）：82⁃90.

［5］刘晓雪，邬志军.2020/2021榨季国内外食糖市场回顾与2021/2022榨季展望［J］.中国糖料，2021，43（4）：81⁃88.

LIU X X，WU Z J.Domestic and foreign sugar markets in 2020/2021 crushing season and their prospect for 2021/2022 crushing season［J］.Sugar Crops of China，2021，43（4）：81⁃88.

［6］CAO Z X，WANG X P，GAO Y.Effect of plant growth regulators on cotton seedling root growth parameters and enzyme activity［J］.Plants，2022，11（21）：2964.

［7］张特，王蜜蜂，赵强.滴施缩节胺与氮肥对棉花生长发育及产量的影响［J］.作物学报，2022，48（2）：396⁃409.

ZHANG T，WANG M F，ZHAO Q.Effects of DPC and nitrogen fertilizer through drip irrigation on growth and yield in cotton［J］.Acta Agronomica Sinica，2022，48 （2）：396⁃409.

［8］马正波，董学瑞，房孟颖，等. 矮壮素配合氮肥全基施对华北夏玉米氮素利用的调控效应［J］.应用生态学报，2021，32（3）：931⁃941.

MA Z B，DONG X R，FANG M Y，et al.Effects of basic application of chlorocholine chloride combined with nitrogen fertilizer on nitrogen use of summer maize in North China Plain［J］. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2021，32（3）：931⁃941.

［9］ZHAO H H，ZHENG D F，FENG N J，et al.Different physiological and photosynthetic responses of soybean and mungbean at the initial flowering stage under low⁃temperature stress to uniconazole S3307［J］.Russian Journal of Plant Physiology，2022，69（6）：129.

［10］闫艳红，万燕，杨文钰，等.叶面喷施烯效唑对套作大豆花后碳氮代谢及产量的影响［J］.大豆科学，2015，34（1）：75⁃81.

YAN Y H，WAN Y，YANG W Y，et al.Effect of spraying uniconazole on carbon and nitrogen metabolism and yield of relay strip intercropping soybean［J］.Soybean Science，2015，34（1）：75⁃81.

［11］焦阳，马英，张振，等.乙烯利对苦瓜幼苗内源激素代谢及相关调控基因表达的影响［J］.西北植物学报，2022，42（7）：1180⁃1188.

JIAO Y，MA Y，ZHANG Z，et al.Effect of ethephon on endogenous hormone metabolism and related genes expression in bitter melon seedlings［J］. Acta Botanica Boreali⁃Occidentalia Sinica，2022，42（7）：1180⁃1188.

［12］邵昕怡，胡华兵，王荣华，等.不同浓度胺鲜酯对甜菜种子萌发的影响［J］.中国糖料，2022，44（3）：60⁃64.

SHAO X Y，HU H B，WANG R H，et al.Effects of different concentrations of diethyl aminoethyl hexanoate （DA⁃6）on germination of sugar beet seeds［J］.Sugar Crops of China，2022，44（3）：60⁃64.

［13］沙红，高燕，杨洪泽，等.6-苄基腺嘌呤对甜菜种子萌发的影响［J］.中国糖料，2015，37（4）：28⁃29.

SHA H，GAO Y，YANG H Z，et al.Effect of 6⁃benzyladenine on sugarbeet seed vigor and bud［J］.Sugar Crops of China，2015，37（4）：28⁃29.

［14］王鑫，刘丹，陈婧婷，等.外源BR对盐碱胁迫下甜菜内源激素含量及保护酶活性的影响［J］.西北农林科技大学学报（自然科学版），2021，49（7）：20⁃30.

WANG X，LIU D，CHEN J T，et al.Effects of exogenous BR on endogenous hormone and protective enzyme activities in sugar beet under saline⁃alkali stress［J］.Journal of Northwest A & F University（Natural Science Edition），2021，49（7）：20⁃30.

［15］刘丹，郭广昊，刘磊，等.外源喷施油菜素内酯对碱胁迫下甜菜生长的影响［J］.西北农业学报，2018，27（10）：1461⁃1469.

LIU D，GUO G H，LIU L，et al.Effects of exogenous application of brassinolide on sugar beet growth under alkali stress［J］.Acta Agriculturae Boreali⁃occidentalis Sinica，2018，27（10）：1461⁃1469.

［16］张子臻.外源油菜素甾醇类化合物对甜菜产质量的影响［D］.呼和浩特：内蒙古农业大学，2019.

ZHANG Z Z.Effects of exogenous brassinosteroids on yield and quality of sugar beet［D］.Hohhot：Inner Mongolia Agricultural University，2019.

［17］ARNON D I. Copper enzymes in isolated chloroplasts.polyphenoloxidase in Beta vulgaris［J］.Plant Physiology，1949，24（1）：1⁃15.

［18］SMITH M R，RAO I M，MERCHANT A.Source⁃sink relationships in crop plants and their influence on yield development and nutritional quality［J］.Frontiers in Plant Science，2018，9：1889.

［19］周海燕，张少英，李国龙，等.甜菜源库关系的研究［J］.华北农学报，2008，23（3）：94⁃99.

ZHOU H Y，ZHANG S Y，LI G L，et al.Research on source⁃sink relationship of sugar beet（Beta vulgaris L.）［J］. Acta Agriculturae Boreali⁃Sinica，2008，23（3）：94⁃99.

［20］李文姗，张俊尧，王家勇，等.不同滴施量艾氟迪对棉花光合特性及成铃规律的影响［J］.河南农业科学，2023，52（1）：53⁃60.

LI W S，ZHANG J Y，WANG J Y，et al.Effects of different dosages of AFD on photosynthetic characteristics and boll formation of cotton［J］.Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences，2023，52（1）：53⁃60.

［21］袁刘正，柳家友，王会强，等.叶面肥和生长调节剂对玉米遮荫胁迫的缓解作用［J］.河南农业科学，2018，47（4）：21⁃25.

YUAN L Z，LIU J Y，WANG H Q，et al.Mitigative effects of growth regulator and foliar fertilizer on maize under shading stress［J］.Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences，2018，47（4）：21⁃25.

［22］高聚林，刘克礼，张宝林，等.马铃薯干物质积累与分配规律的研究［J］.中国马铃薯，2003，17（4）：209⁃212.

GAO J L，LIU K L，ZHANG B L，et al.Accumulation and distribution of dry matter in potato［J］.Chinese Potato，2003，17（4）：209⁃212.

［23］董志君，张建军，范永明，等.3种植物生长延缓剂对盆栽芍药的矮化效应［J］.东北林业大学学报，2020，48（9）：62⁃66.

DONG Z J，ZHANG J J，FAN Y M，et al.Dwarfing effects of paclobutrazol，unicnazleand chlormequat on potted Paeonia lactiflora［J］.Journal of Northeast Forestry University，2020，48（9）：62⁃66.

［24］朱茂成，杨锦昌，邹文涛，等.植物生长延缓剂对米老排幼苗生理特性的影响［J］.森林与环境学报，2022，42（4）：384⁃391.

ZHU M C，YANG J C，ZOU W T，et al.Effects of plant growth retardants on physiological characteristics of Mytilaria laosensis seedlings［J］.Journal of Forest and Environment，2022，42（4）：384⁃391.

［25］任若飞，赵强，王自然，等.滴施烯效唑复配促进剂对棉花生长发育及产量、品质的影响［J］.河南农业科学，2024，53（3）：68⁃77.

REN R F，ZHAO Q，WANG Z R，et al.Effect of drip application of uniconazole compound promoter on the growth，development，yield and quality of cotton［J］.Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences，2024，53（3）：68⁃77.

［26］杨航，赵雅姣，刘晓静.紫花苜蓿/燕麦间作的光合特征及其对产量的调控效应［J］.草地学报，2023，31 （1）：187⁃195.

YANG H，ZHAO Y J，LIU X J.Effects on photosynthesis characteristics and yield regulations in the alfalfa/oat intercropping［J］.Acta Agrestia Sinica，2023，31（1）：187⁃195.

［27］ABICHOU M， DE SOLAN B， ANDRIEU B.Architectural response of wheat cultivars to row spacing reveals altered perception of plant density［J］.Frontiers in Plant Science，2019，10：999.

［28］陈嘉敏，刘瑞显，张国伟，等.二氢卟吩铁对花针期干旱及复水后花生叶片光合特性的影响［J］.花生学报，2023，52（1）：52⁃62.

CHEN J M，LIU R X，ZHANG G W，et al.Effects of iron chlorin e6 on photosynthetic characteristics of peanut leaves under drought stress and after rewatering at flowering⁃pegging stage［J］.Journal of Peanut Science，2023，52（1）：52⁃62.

［29］丁凯鑫，冯乃杰，郑殿峰，等.植物生长调节剂对赤豆鼓粒期光合特性及氮代谢的影响［J］.核农学报，2022，36（12）：2510⁃2518.

DING K X，FENG N J，ZHENG D F，et al.Effects of plant growth regulators on photosynthetic characteristics and nitrogen metabolism of adzuki bean during seed filling stage［J］.Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences，2022，36（12）：2510⁃2518.

［30］COOKE D A，SCOTT R K. The sugar beet crop［M］.Dordrecht：Springer Netherlands，1993.

［31］潘竟海，张恒，阿不都卡地尔·库尔班，等.矮壮素对甜菜糖分积累及产量形成的影响［J］.新疆农业科学，2020，57（8）：1411⁃1420.

PAN J H，ZHANG H，ABDUKADIER K，et al.Effect of chlorpromazine on sugar accumulation and yield formation of sugar beet［J］.Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences，2020，57（8）：1411⁃1420.

[1]	CHAI Guozhu, WANG Meihui, QIU Zejiang, YANG Qifan, YUAN Fang. Effect of Piriformospora indica on Growth and Physiological Characteristics of Endangered Tibetan Medicine Codonopsis convolvulacea Kurz.var.vinciflora（Kom.）L.T.Shen [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(3): 71-76.
[2]	GAO Cuimin, TIAN Yuan, ZHANG Ruiqing, HE Fang, HAN Weifeng, ZHANG Yunhong, PAN Xiaoying, YANG Yonghui. Effects of Irrigation Methods on Crop Yield and Water⁃Nitrogen Use Efficiency under Wheat⁃Peanut Rotation System [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(3): 31-39.
[3]	LIU Xiaoyu, XIAO Donglai, YANG Chi, LIN Hui, JIANG Xiaoling, MA Lu. Effects of Nutritional Additives on Growth of Sparassis latifolia [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(2): 107-115.
[4]	LÜ Shuli, DING Fang, TIAN Zhuangbo. Effects of Spraying Prohexadione Calcium on Mechanical Harvesting Agronomic Characters，Yield and Quality of Sesame under Different Densities [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(2): 58-65.
[5]	ZHANG Ning, ZHANG Yongli, LIU Yujie, TU Xiaoju, ZHOU Zhonghua, LIU Aiyu. Effect of Mepenzolate Compounding with Plant Growth Regulator on Spatiotemporal Distribution of Boll Formation and Endogenous Hormones in Cotton [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(2): 48-57.
[6]	LIU Jiaqi, ZOU Yiping, YIN Yawen, HAO Mingzhuo. Effects of Different Plant Growth Regulators on the Fruit Quality of Ilex verticillata [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(1): 128-135.
[7]	LI Kai, LUO Shiwu, WANG Zhan, YANG Junxue, WANG Yong, WANG Fei, ZHANG Jiantong. Effects of Different Types of Surface Mulching on Soil Environment and Growth of Forage Crop in Ningxia Dry Farming Area [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(1): 90-100.
[8]	QI Tiancheng, LI Yinghai, LI Yangyang. Effects of Different Irrigation and Fertilization Rates on the Growth，Yield and Quality of Fennel [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(1): 66-75.
[9]	ZHANG Aiqin, GUO Bin, LIU Lilong, LI Xuhua, WANG Qing, XU Rui, ZHANG Huan. Comprehensive Evaluation of Nutritional Quality of Foxtail Millet Based on Principal Component Analysis and Membership Function Method [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 54(1): 28-39.
[10]	CHENG Peijun, HAO Haohao, LI Xiang, LI Liang, ZHANG Xiang, TANG Peipei , WANG Xun, SI Xianzong, SUO Yanyan, WU Junlin, XU Fengdan, LI Qian, MA Xinjun, YAN Meng. Effects of Cake Fertilizer and Microbial Agents on the Yield and Quality of Flue‑Cured Tobacco and Soil Microbial Characteristics [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(9): 57-65.
[11]	LIANG Xiaohong, CAO Xiong, ZHANG Ruidong, HUANG Minjia, LIU Jing, NAN Huailin, WANG Songyu. Effects of One‑off Basal Application of Different Slow Controlled Release Urea on Yield and Nitrogen Utilization of Sorghum [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(9): 28-36.
[12]	ZHANG Panpan, LI Chuan, ZHANG Meiwei, YU Xiaohong, MU Weilin, GUO Hanxiao, QIAO Jiangfang, ZHANG Guitang. Effect of Nitrogen and Zinc Application on Filling Characteristics of Grains at Different Positions of Maize Ear [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(9): 16-27.
[13]	LI Fangjie, CHANG Zhijie, SHI Dakun, WEI Xiaoyi, WEI Feng, HONG Defeng, MA Junfeng, ZHENG Qiudao. Effects of Intercropping of Different Genotypes of Maize on Stomatal Characteristics and Yield [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(8): 21-29.
[14]	WANG Jingying, WANG Jiaxu, CHEN Lina, WANG Xiuping. Effect of Halloysite Nanotubes on Growth of Wheat under Copper Stress [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(7): 28-34.
[15]	LI Xiaode, YANG Yuxin, ZHU Chenjia, LI Yujia, CHEN Shulin, YIN Guihong, DONG Chunhao, WANG Daowen, ZHANG Kunpu. Genetic Dissection of Dwarf Genes in Varieties（Lines）Derived from Core Wheat Parent Zhou 8425B [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(7): 21-27.