Effect of Rice‑Fish‑Chicken Symbiosis on Paddy Soil Nutrient and Rice Yield under Ridge Cultivation

doi:10.15933/j.cnki.1004-3268.2021.08.002

Abstract

Abstract: Four treatments were set up，including rice‑fish‑chicken pattern under ridge cultivation（RFC），rice‑fish pattern under ridge cultivation（RF），rice‑chicken pattern under ridge cultivation（RC）and rice ridge cultivation（CK），and the effects of rice‑fish‑chicken symbiosis on soil nutrient and rice yield were studied under ridge cultivation，so as to provide scientific basis for the development and popularization of rice‑fish‑chicken pattern. The results showed that compared with CK，RC and RFC treatments increased the contents of soil total nitrogen and total phosphorus at mature stage in two‑year experiments，and the total phosphorus contents of RC and RFC treatments were significantly higher than those of CK；the contents of alkali‑hydrolyzable nitrogen and available phosphorus of RC and RFC treatments were significantly higher than those of CK at mature stage in two‑year experiments，the contents of available potassium of RFC treatment were significantly higher than those of CK at full heading stage in two‑year experiments；the soil organic matter contents of RFC，RC and RF treatments were significantly higher than those of CK at mature stage in two‑year experiments. In 2018，the rice yield of RF treatment increased by 5. 75% compared with CK，and there was no significant difference among the treatments. In 2019，the rice yields of RFC，RC and RF treatments significantly increased by16. 29%，14. 03% and 9. 35% compared with CK respectively. In conclusion，RC and RFC treatments can improve soil nutrient content and rice yield，and could be used as the optimal patterns for comprehensive cultivation in paddy field，especially RFC treatment.

Key words: Ridge cultivation, Rice?fish?chicken symbiosis, Soil nutrient, Rice yield

摘要： 于2018—2019 年分别设置垄作稻鱼鸡（RFC）、垄作稻鱼（RF）、垄作稻鸡（RC）和垄作单稻（CK）4个处理，研究垄作稻鱼鸡共生对土壤养分含量及水稻产量的影响，以期为垄作稻鱼鸡共生模式的发展和推广提供科学依据。结果表明：与CK相比，2 a RC、RFC处理水稻成熟期土壤全氮、全磷含量均提高，且RC、RFC处理全磷含量与CK均达到显著性差异；2 a RC、RFC处理成熟期土壤碱解氮、速效磷含量均显著高于CK，RFC处理齐穗期速效钾含量均显著高于CK；2 a RFC、RC、RF处理成熟期土壤有机质含量均显著高于CK。2018年RF处理水稻产量较CK提高5.75%，各处理间无显著差异，2019年RFC、RC、RF处理水稻产量均显著高于CK，增幅分别为16.29%、14.03%、9.35%。综上可知，RC和RFC处理均能够提高土壤养分含量和水稻产量，可作为稻田综合种养的优选模式，尤其是RFC处理。

关键词: 垄作栽培, 稻鱼鸡共生, 土壤养分, 水稻产量

CLC Number:

S511

MA Weiwei, CHEN Can, HUANG Huang, REN Bo, ZHOU Jing, LI Guixiang, WANG Ren. Effect of Rice‑Fish‑Chicken Symbiosis on Paddy Soil Nutrient and Rice Yield under Ridge Cultivation[J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(8): 9-17.

马微微, 陈灿, 黄璜, 任勃, 周晶, 李桂香, 王忍. 垄作稻鱼鸡共生对稻田土壤养分含量及水稻产量的影响[J]. 河南农业科学, 2021, 50(8): 9-17.

Figures/Tables 7

References

［1］尹成杰. 后疫情时代粮食发展与粮食安全［J］.农业经济问题，2021（1）：4‑13.
YIN C J.Food development and food security in post epidemic era development and food security in post epidemic era［J］.Issues in Agricultural Economy，2021（1）：4‑13.
［2］沈建凯.稻田养鸭对土壤及杂草生物多样性的影响［D］.长沙：湖南农业大学，2010.
SHEN J K.Effects of rice‑duck eco‑farming on boil and biodiversity of weed in paddy fields［D］.Changsha：Hunan Agricultural University，2010.
［3］胡亮亮.农业生物种间互惠的生态系统功能［D］.杭州：浙江大学，2014.
HU L L.Ecosystem functioning of facilitation between co‑cultured species［D］.Hangzhou：Zhejiang University，2014.
［4］兰国俊，胡雪峰，程畅，等.稻鸭共生对土壤养分和水稻病虫害防控的影响［J/OL］.土壤学报，2020［2021‑01‑20］.https：//kns. cnki. net/KXReader/Detail？TIMESTAMP=637605563083297846&DBCODE=CAPJ&TABLEName=CAPJLAST&FileName=TRXB20200825000&RESULT=1&SIGN=fWwjMoLiEZFUev%2blDy6rLIdFyOY%3d#.
LAN G J，HU X F，CHENG C，et al.Effects of raising duck in paddy field on soil nutrients and rice pests and
diseases control ［J/OL］.Acta Pedologica Sinica，2020［2021‑01‑20］.https：//kns. cnki. net/KXReader/Detail？TIMESTAMP=637605563083297846&DBCODE=CAPJ&TABLEName=CAPJLAST&FileName=TRXB20200825000&RESULT=1&SIGN=fWwjMoLiEZFUev%2blDy6rLIdFyOY%3d#.
［5］崔文超，焦雯珺，闵庆文，等.土地流转背景下不同经营规模青田稻鱼共生系统的环境影响差异：基于碳足迹的实证研究［J］.应用生态学报，2020，31（12）：4125‑4133.
CUI W C，JIAO W J，MIN Q W，et al. Environmental impact differences in qingtian rice‑fish culture system at different management scales in the context of land transfer：An empirical study with the carbon footprint method［J］.Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2020，31（12）：4125‑4133.
［6］刘贵斌，周江伟，王忍，等. 垄作稻鱼鸡共生对水稻农艺性状和产量的影响［J］.江苏农业科学，2018，46（13）：65‑73.
LIU G B，ZHOU J W，WANG R，et al.Effects of rice‑fish‑chicken symbiosis on agronomic traits and yield of rice under rice ridge cultivation ［J］.Jiangsu Agricultural Sciences，2018，46（13）：65‑73.
［7］刘广根，付爱昌，邓进根.鳖虾稻生态种养技术［J］.渔业致富指南，2019（13）：47‑48.
LIU G G，FU A C，DENG J G.Ecological cultivation techniques of turtle，shrimp and rice［J］. Fishery Guide to
be Rich，2019（13）：47‑48.
［8］张益之.南方稻区水稻高产栽培技术研究［J］.配套技术，2017，35（6）：61‑62.
ZHANG Y Z. Study on high yield cultivation techniques of rice in southern rice region［J］. Matching Technology，2017，35（6）：61‑62.
［9］余经纬，黄巍，李玉成，等.稻田生态综合种养模式对土壤理化性质及腐殖质的影响［J］.生物学杂志，2020，37（3）：81‑85.
YU J W，HUANG W，LI Y C，et al.Effects of ecological comprehensive planting and breeding patterns on soil physical and chemical properties and humus in paddy fields［J］.Journal of Biology，2020，37（3）：81‑85.
［10］王忍，伍佳，吕广动，等.稻草还田+稻田养鸭对土壤养分及水稻生物量和产量的影响［J］.西南农业学报，2020，33（1）：98‑103.
WANG R，WU J，LÜ G D，et al.Effects of rice straw returning with rice‑ducking on soil nutrients and rice biomass and rice yield［J］. Southwest China Journal of Agricultural Sciences，2020，33（1）：98‑103.
［11］ YANG Y，HANG H C，HU X J，et al.Characteristics of growth and yield formation of rice in rice‑fish farming
system［J］.Agricultural Sciences in China，2006，5（2）：103‑110.
［12］李艳蔷，晏群.稻鳅共生种养模式试验研究［J］.中国农业资源与区划，2018，39（5）：54‑60.
LI Y Q，YAN Q.Experimental study on symbiotic breeding model of rice loach［J］.Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning，2018，39（5）：54‑60.
［13］罗衡.养殖鳖的引入对稻田水稻生长、产量及土壤微生物群落的影响［D］.上海：上海海洋大学，2017.
LUO H.The Influence of cultured turtle introduction on rice growth，yield and soil microbial community［D］.Shanghai：Shanghai Ocean University，2017.
［14］佘玮，黄璜，郑华斌，等.垄作梯式栽培对水稻养分吸收利用和根区土壤养分的影响［J］.作物研究，2015，29（4）：357‑361.
YU W，HUANG H，ZHENG H B，et al. Effects of ridge and terraced rice farming on nutrient uptake and utilization in rice and soil nutrient contents［J］.Crop Research，2015，29（4）：357‑361.
［15］ SHA D RACK O N，NANCY N K，CHARLES K K G，et al.Effect of potato hilling on soil temperature，soil moisture distribution and sediment yield on a sloping terrain［J］.Soil Till Res，2018，184：24‑36.
［16］ GU Y J，HAN C L，KONG M.Plastic film mulch promotes high alfalfa production with phosphorus‑saving and low risk of soil nitrogen loss［J］.Field Crops Res，2018，229：44‑54.
［17］ CHEN Y Z，CHAI S X，TIAN H H，et al.Straw strips mulch on furrows improves water use efficiency and yield of potato in a rainfed semiarid area［J］.Agric Water Manag，2019，211：142‑151.
［18］梁玉刚，陈奕沙，陈璐，等.垄作稻-鱼-鸡共生对水稻茎秆倒伏、穗部性状及产量的影响［J］.中国生态农业学报，2021，29（2）：379‑388.
LIANG Y G，CHEN Y S，CHEN L，et al.Effect of rice‑fish‑chicken ridge cultivation on stem lodging resistance，panicle traits，and yield of rice［J］.Chinese Journal of Eco‑Agriculture，2021，29（2）：379‑388.
［19］梁玉刚，李静怡，王丹，等.垄作稻鱼鸡共生对水稻群体生长特性及产量形成的影响［J］.中国农业科技导报，2020，22（11）：165‑175.
LIANG Y G，LI J Y，WANG D，et al.Impact of rice‑fish‑chicken ridge cultivation on rice population growth and yield［J］.Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology，2020，22（11）：165‑175.
［20］陈杨，扈婷，郑华斌，等.水稻垄作栽培技术研究进展［J］.作物研究，2011，25（6）：616‑620.
CHEN Y，HU T，ZHENG H B，et al. Research progress on ridge culture technology of rice［J］.Crop Research，2011，25（6）：616‑620.
［21］刘贵斌. 垄作稻鱼鸡共生对水稻产量及农田环境的影响［D］. 长沙：湖南农业大学，2018.
LIU G B. Effect of rice‑fish‑chicken symbiosis on rice yield and paddy field environment under rice ridge cultivation［D］. Changsha： Hunan Agricultural University，2018.
［22］高明，张磊，魏朝富，等.稻田长期垄作免耕对水稻产量及土壤肥力的影响研究［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2004，10（4）：343‑348，354.
GAO M，ZHANG L，WEI C F，et al.Study of the changes of the rice yield and soil fertility on the paddy field under long‑term no‑tillage and ridge culture conditions［J］.Plant Nutrition and Fertilizer Science，2004，10（4）：343‑348，354.
［23］孙刚，房岩，韩国军，等.稻-鱼复合生态系统对水田土壤理化性状的影响［J］.中国土壤与肥料，2009（4）：21‑24.
SUN G，FANG Y，HAN G J，et al.Effects of rice fish complex ecosystem on physical and chemical properties of paddy soi［l J］.Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China，2009（4）：21‑24.
［24］黄国勤.稻田养鱼的价值与效益［J］.耕作与栽培，2009（4）：49‑51.
HUANG G Q.Value and benefit of fish culture in paddy field［J］.Tillage and Cultivation，2009（4）：49‑51.
［25］张志毅，熊又升，徐祥玉，等.免耕起垄对冷浸田土壤有机碳活性的影响［J］.土壤通报，2015，46（1）：192‑197.
ZHANG Z Y，XIONG Y S，XU X Y，et al.Effects of no‑tillage and combing ridge on soil organic carbon active in cold waterlogged paddy field［J］.Chinese Journal of Soil Science，2015，46（1）：192‑197.
［26］郑华斌.水稻垄作梯式栽培的水分利用及其增产机制［D］.长沙：湖南农业大学，2014.
ZHENG H B. The law of water utilization and its mechanism of increasing yield of rice ridge tillage &terrace cultivation technology［D］.Changsha：Hunan Agricultural University，2018.
［27］李成芳，曹凑贵，汪金平，等.稻鸭稻鱼共作生态系统N素平衡的研究［J］.农业环境科学学报，2008，27（4）：1326‑1334.
LI C F，CAO C G，WANG J P，et al.Studies on nitrogen cycling in integrated rice‑duck，rice‑fish ecosystems［J］.Journal of Agro‑Environment Science，2008，27（4）：1326‑1334.
［28］李文淑，曾玉清，吕泽林，等.水稻垄作栽培增产效果及原因分析［J］.农业科技通讯，2014（12）：118‑122.
LI W S，ZENG Y Q，LÜ Z L，et al.Effect of ridge culture on rice yield and its causes［J］.Bulletin of Agricultural Science and Technology，2014（12）：118‑122.
［29］韦本辉，刘斌，甘秀芹，等.粉垄栽培对水稻产量和品质的影响［J］.中国农业科学，2012，45（19）：3946‑3954.
WEI B H，LI B，GAN X Q，et al.Effect of Fenlong cultivation on yield and quality of rice［J］.Scientia Agricultura Sinica，2012，45（19）：3946‑3954.
［30］郭海松，徐冠洪，刘其根.青田稻-鱼共生系统水稻密度对水稻生长及产量构成的影［J］.上海海洋大学学报，2019，28（6）：890‑901.
GUO H S，XU G H，LI Q G. Effects of rice density on rice growth and yield components in rice fish symbiotic system in Qingtian［J］. Journal of Shanghai Ocean University，2019，28（6）：890‑901.

[1]	LI Shanmin, ZENG Xinhua, HUANG Weichang, FU Hao, HUANG Qingjun. Effects of Different Forest Type on the Growth of Bletilla striata and Diversity of Endophytic Fungi [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(7): 70-80.
[2]	WANG Cong, LI Ming, QIU Guangwei, WANG Lichun, LIU Lingling, WANG Huaipeng, PANG Ze , TANG Chunshuang, SUN Jiying. Effects of Different Planting Pattern on Soil Physical and Chemical Properties of Heilongjiang Black Soil [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(2): 74-83.
[3]	SHEN Yue, LI Qianyi, ZHAO Wenhui, WANG Guiliang, QIAN Xiaoqing. Nutrient Status and Fertility Evaluation of Farmland Soil in Donghai County [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(12): 77-87.
[4]	LI Qian, JIA Xiaoguo, LI Liang, ZHANG Xiang, CHENG Yuyuan, LI Peng. Spatial‑Temporal Variability of Nutrients and Assessment of Fertility in Tobacco‑Planting Soil in Hilly Areas of Southwest Henan [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(1): 73-85.
[5]	LIU Yajun, WANG Wenjing, LI Min, WANG Honggang, CHU Fengli, HU Qiguo. Effects of Combined Application of Inorganic Fertilizer and Organic Fertilizer on Soil Nutrient Changes and Microbial Carbon Source Metabolism in Sweetpotato Field [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 51(7): 75-84.
[6]	ZHANG Huan, GAO Xiaofeng, LEI Mengyao, TAO Aili, LI Yuying, YAO Gang. Multivariate Analysis of the Relationship between Soil Nutrients and Fruit Quality and Optimization of Soil Nutrients in Soft‑seed Pomegranate Orchards [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 51(4): 111-119.
[7]	SUN Shijun, LIU Qi, YE Yingjie, WEI Na, HAO Shuiyuan. Effects of Humic Acid on Soil Nutrients and Microbial Community Structure of Cucumber with Different Continuous Cropping Years in Greenhouse [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 51(2): 65-74.
[8]	XU Sisi , LÜ Xuemei, ZHOU Meng, SUI Yueyu, JIAO Xiaoguang. Effects of Straw Deep Burial Combined with Nitrogen Fertilizer on Organic Carbon Components and Nutrients in Black Soils [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 51(12): 63-72.
[9]	QIN Tao. Effects of Pepper Straw Returning Amount on Rhizosphere Soil Microenvironment and Quality of Watermelon [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(9): 79-86.
[10]	HAN Jin, HAN Qiujing, MA Jing, LU Jian, YAO Pengwei, WU Qinyang, YE Xiefeng, WU Furu. Effects of Straw Returning on Soil Nutrients and Salinity in Luoyang Tobacco‑Growing Areas [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(8): 76-84.
[11]	WU Jicheng, PAN Xiaoying, YANG Yonghui, GAO Cuimin, WANG Yue, . Effects of Long⁃term Application of Biogas Slurry on Soil Nutrient Content and Enzyme Activity [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(7): 76-86.
[12]	XUE Jinyuan, XU Fangfang, WANG Juanjuan, YANG Jianchang, WANG Guiliang, QIAN Xiaoqing. Effects of Nitrogen Reducing and Density Increasing on Rice Yield, Nitrogen Uptake and Nutrient Distribution in Soil Profile [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(6): 82-90.
[13]	ZHANG Jun, CAI Debao, YANG Shuqiong, CHEN Xiuwen, CHEN Jibao. Evaluation on Farmland Soil Fertility in Danjiangkou Reservoir Area Based on Principal Component Analysis and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis:A Case Study of Xichuan County [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(4): 79-87.
[14]	ZHANG Yin, YU Zhengjun, WANG Ren, LÜ Guangdong, CHEN Can, HUANG Huang, CHEN Zhifeng. Effects of Different Duck Varieties on Soil Physical and Chemical Properties，Rice Yield and Economic Benefit of Rice‐Duck Symbiosis System [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(12): 23-31.
[15]	CHEN Lu, CHEN Can, HUANG Huang , LONG Binqing, MA Weiwei, WANG Ren, ZHANG Yin. Effect of Different Rice‐Fish Modes on Yield and Quality of Ratooning Rice [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(12): 32-38.