Effect of Continuous Application of Municipal Standardized Sewage Sludge on the Risk of Heavy Metal Pollution in Apples and Orchard Soil

doi:10.15933/j.cnki.1004-3268.2024.11.009

Abstract

Abstract: To investigate the impact of continuous application of municipal sludge on the risk of heavy metal contamination in apples and orchard soil，a field experiment was conducted with four treatments：conventional fertilization（T1），moderate sludge application（T2），high sludge application（T3）and low sludge application（T4）.The study analyzed the risk of heavy metal contamination in apples and soil under different sludge application rates and durations.The results indicated that the concentrations of Cd，Cr，Pb，Hg，and As in apples did not exceed the regulatory limits.After three years of sludge application，the single‑factor pollution indexes for heavy metals in the soil were below the warning thresholds by 71.98% to 75.98%，66.57% to 69.90%，92.32% to 94.01%，78.59% to 90.40%，and 17.22% to 23.29%，respectively.The Nemerow comprehensive pollution index and potential ecological risk index were also below the warming thresholds by 9.51% to 16.08% and 82.50% to 86.75%，respectively.Following three years of sludge application，the single‑factor pollution index for Hg and As increased by 29.52 times and 83. 14% compared to background levels. The potential ecological risk index for treatments T2 to T4 increased by 78.38%，95.69% and 48.18% respectively，compared to background values. The potential ecological risk contribution rate of Hg increased from 11.00%—17.02% to 19.32%—33.70%，while As increased from 21.55%—24.61% to 31.54%—39.17%. Based on the calculations for Cd and Hg，the safe application duration for sludge was relatively shorter，ranging from 32.30 to 116.31 years and from 36.07 to 129.91 years，respectively. In summary，after the continuous application of sewage sludge for three years，both apple fruit and soil remained in an uncontaminated state. However，with the increasing of sludge application duration，the single‑factor pollution index for Hg and As，comprehensive pollution index and potential ecological risks all increased，with Hg and As being the primary contributing factors.Based on the safe application duration of sludge，Cd and Hg emerged as the most significant limiting elements.The rational utilization of sludge does not lead to heavy metal contamination in the soil.

Key words: Apple, Orchard soil, Municipal standardized sewage sludge, Risk of heavy metal pollution

摘要： 为探究连续施用生活污泥对苹果和果园土壤重金属污染风险的影响，通过田间试验，设置常规施肥（T1）、中量施用污泥（T2）、高量施用污泥（T3）和低量施用污泥（T4）4个处理，分析污泥不同用量、不同施用年限苹果和土壤的重金属污染风险。结果表明，苹果中的Cd、Cr、Pb、Hg和As含量均未超过限量标准。施用污泥3 a，土壤重金属的单因子污染指数分别低于警戒线71.98%~75.98%、66.57%~69.90%、92.32%~94.01%、78.59%~90.40%、17.22%~23.29%；内梅罗综合污染指数和潜在生态风险指数分别低于警戒线9.51%~16.08%、82.50%~86.75%。施用污泥3 a，Hg和As含量的单因子污染指数分别比背景值增长29.52倍、83.14%。T2—T4处理的潜在生态风险指数与背景值相比升高78.38%、95.69%、48.18%，Hg的潜在生态风险贡献率从11.00%~17.02% 增长至19.32%~33.70%，As 从21.55%~24.61% 增长至31.54%~39.17%。基于Cd和Hg计算的污泥安全施用年限较短，为32.30~116.31、36.07~129.91 a。综上，连续施用生活污泥3 a，苹果果实和土壤均处于无污染状态；随施污泥年限增加，土壤单因子污染指数（Hg和As）、综合污染指数和潜在生态风险均升高，其中Hg和As是主要贡献因子。基于施肥量计算的污泥安全施用年限，Cd和Hg是最主要的限制性元素。污泥合理利用不会引起土壤重金属污染。

关键词: 苹果, 果园土壤, 城镇达标生活污泥, 重金属污染风险

CLC Number:

X703

BAI Jiayun, XU Junxiang, SUN Qinping, YAO Hai, YANG Yingjie, HE Liang, GAO Shitao, XIONG Jianjun, LIU Yanpeng. Effect of Continuous Application of Municipal Standardized Sewage Sludge on the Risk of Heavy Metal Pollution in Apples and Orchard Soil[J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(11): 83-92.

白家云, 许俊香, 孙钦平, 姚海, 杨英杰, 和亮, 高始涛, 熊建军, 刘艳鹏. 连续施用城镇达标生活污泥对苹果和果园土壤重金属污染风险的影响[J]. 河南农业科学, 2024, 53(11): 83-92.

References

［1］徐少奇，陈文杰，解林奇，等.我国有机废弃物资源总量及养分利用潜力［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2022，28（8）：1341‑1352.
XU S Q，CHEN W J，XIE L Q，et al.Organic waste resources and nutrient utilization potential in China［J］.Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2022，28（8）：1341‑1352.
［2］江宇.沈阳市政污泥重金属污染特征及草坪基质应用研究［D］.沈阳：沈阳大学，2022.
JIANG Y.Study on heavy metal pollution characteristics of municipal sludge and application of turf substrate in Shenyang［D］.Shenyang：Shenyang University，2022.
［3］杨丽标，邹国元，张丽娟，等.城市污泥农用处置研究进展［J］.中国农学通报，2008，24（1）：420‑424.
YANG L B，ZOU G Y，ZHANG L J，et al.Progress in research on agricultural application of sewage sludge［J］.Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin，2008，24（1）：420‑424.
［4］路瑞娟，付杰，王晨晨，等.城市污泥处理过程中重金属迁移转化特性研究进展［J］.环境工程技术学报，2023，13（1）：318‑324.
LU R J，FU J，WANG C C，et al.Research progress on the characteristics of heavy metal transfer and transformation in municipal sludge treatment［J］.Journal of Environmental Engineering Technology，2023，13（1）：318‑324.
［5］HALECKI W，GASIOREK M，GAMBUS F，et al.The potential of hydrated and dehydrated sewage sludge discharges from soil reclamation appliances［J］.Ecology Environment & Conservation，2016，25（6）：1935‑1941.
［6］冀拯宇，周吉祥，郭康莉，等.连续施用无害化污泥堆肥对沙质潮土肥力的影响［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2018，24（5）：1276‑1284.
JI Z Y，ZHOU J X，GUO K L，et al.Effects of continuous application of non‑hazardous sewage sludge compost on fertility of sandy fluvo‑aquic soil［J］.Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2018，24（5）：1276‑1284.
［7］曹迟，周晓天，高羽欣，等.污泥堆肥部分替代化肥对铬污染耕地玉米生长的影响［J］.农业环境科学学报，2023，42（11）：2453‑2463.
CAO C，ZHOU X T，GAO Y X，et al.Effects of partial replacement of chemical fertilizer with sludge compost on maize growth in chromium‑contaminated farmland［J］.Journal of Agro‑Environment Science，2023，42（11）：2453‑2463.
［8］陈鸣.城市污水处理厂污泥最终处置方式的探讨［J］.中国给水排水，2000，16（8）：23‑24.
CHEN M.Discussion on the final disposal methods of sludge from urban wastewater treatment plants［J］.China Water & Wastewater，2000，16（8）：23‑24.
［9］杨柯敏，张春燕，张燕，等.城市污泥处理处置方式及现状分析［J］.中国资源综合利用，2012，30（12）：28‑31.
YANG K M，ZHANG C Y，ZHANG Y，et al.The way of municipal sludge treatment and disposal and its status analysis of domestic and foreign sludge treatment and disposal［J］.China Resources Comprehensive Utilization，2012，30（12）：28‑31.
［10］李雪怡，梁远，方小锋，等.北京市污泥处理处置现状总结分析［J］.中国给水排水，2021，37（22）：38‑42.
LI X Y，LIANG Y，FANG X F，et al.Summarization and analysis of sludge treatment and disposal in Beijing［J］.China Water & Wastewater，2021，37（22）：38‑42.
［11］齐星昊.基于生命周期评价的典型剩余污泥处理方法的环境影响比较研究［D］.新乡：河南师范大学，2019.
QI X H.Study on comparation of environmental impacts of typical residual sludge treatment and disposal methods based on life cycle assessment［D］.Xinxiang：Henan Normal University，2019.
［12］王正阳.污泥掺烧与直接焚烧的二噁英生成与控制［J］.电站系统工程，2024，40（2）：13‑16.
WANG Z Y.Dioxins generation and control of sludge co‑combustion with coal and direct incineration［J］.Power System Engineering，2024，40（2）：13‑16.
［13］潘煜，李廉明，宋焜，等.基于化石碳的污泥干化焚烧处置碳排放分析［J］.环境工程学报，2023，17（3）：990‑1000.
PAN Y，LI L M，SONG K，et al.Analysis on carbon emissions of sludge drying and incineration treatment based on fossil carbon［J］.Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2023，17（3）：990‑1000.
［14］安叶，张义斌，黎攀，等.我国市政生活污泥处置现状及经验总结［J］.给水排水，2021，57（S1）：94‑98.
AN Y，ZHANG Y B，LI P，et al.Current situation and experience summary of municipal sewage sludge treatment and disposal in China［J］.Water & Wastewater Engineering，2021，57（S1）：94‑98.
［15］崔超，马富亮，杨文彬，等.污泥产品林地利用长期定位监测及土壤环境质量评价［J］.给水排水，2020，56（12）：36‑40. CUI C，MA F L，YANG W B，et al.Long‑term positioning monitoring and evaluation of soil

environmental quality of sludge product forest land use［J］.Water & Wastewater Engineering，2020，56（12）：36‑40.

［16］国家市场监督管理总局，中国国家标准化管理委员会.农用污泥污染物控制标准：GB 4284—2018［S］.北京：中国标准出版社，2018.
State Administration for Market Regulation，National Standardization Administration. Control standards of pollutants in sludge for agricultural use：GB 4284—2018［S］.Beijing：Standards Press of China，2018.
［17］何孟轲，郭俊娒，杨俊兴，等.典型铅锌企业周边农田重金属富集植物筛选［J］.中国生态农业学报（中英文），2023，31（6）：954‑966.
HE M K，GUO J M，YANG J X，et al.Screening of accumulating plants in farmland surrounding typical lead and zinc smelting enterprises［J］.Chinese Journal of Eco‑Agriculture，2023，31（6）：954‑966.
［18］廖启林，刘聪，蔡玉曼，等.江苏典型地区水稻与小麦籽实中元素生物富集系数（BCF）初步研究［J］.中国地质，2013，40（1）：331‑340.
LIAO Q L，LIU C，CAI Y M，et al.A preliminary study of element bioconcentration factors within milled rice
and wheatmeal in some typical areas of Jiangsu Province［J］.Geology in China，2013，40（1）：331‑340.
［19］张兆永，吉力力·阿不都外力，姜逢清.天山土壤微量（类）重金属的来源解析及潜在生态危害评估［J］.应用生态学报，2014，25（11）：3168‑3176.
ZHANG Z Y，JILILI A，JIANG F Q.Source identification and potential ecological hazards assessment of trace metalloid /heavy metals in the soil of Tianshan Mountains，Xinjiang，China［J］.Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2014，25（11）：3168‑3176.
［20］郑雪云，张金兰，胡晋，等.农用地土壤重金属污染评价及来源解析［J］.环境生态学，2023，5（8）：9‑14.
ZHENG X Y，ZHANG J L，HU J，et al.Assessment and source analysis of soil heavy metal pollution in agricultural land［J］.Environmental Ecology，2023，5（8）：9‑14.
［21］徐争启，倪师军，庹先国，等.潜在生态危害指数法评价中重金属毒性系数计算［J］.环境科学与技术，2008，31（2）：112‑115.
XU Z Q，NI S J，TUO X G，et al.Calculation of heavy metals’ toxicity coefficient in the evaluation of potential ecological risk index［J］.Environmental Science & Technology，2008，31（2）：112‑115.
［22］侯雪艳，欧阳兵，高宁，等.延安市城市污泥农用对土壤及农作物安全性的影响［J］.当代化工研究，2023（7）：62‑65.
HOU X Y，OUYANG B，GAO N，et al.Effect of municipal sludge farming on the safety of soil and crops in Yan’an［J］.Modern Chemical Research，2023（7）：62‑65.
［23］李军，杨云钦，台喜生，等.苦水玫瑰产地土壤重金属污染评价与溯源解析［J］.农业工程学报，2023，39（16）：223‑234.
LI J，YANG Y Q，TAI X S，et al.Contamination evaluation and source apportionment of heavy metals from Kushui rose growing soils［J］.Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering，2023，39（16）：223‑234.
［24］杨鹏，刘家华，李茹莹，等.预处理污泥对Cr在玉米和土壤中迁移转移影响［J］.环境科学与技术，2021，44（5）：109‑115.
YANG P，LIU J H，LI R Y，et al.Effect of ozone‑electric treatment on the enrichment and transfer of heavy metal chromium in sludge［J］.Environmental Science & Technology，2021，44（5）：109‑115.
［25］ADILOĞLU S，GÖKER M.Phytoremediation：Eliminationof hexavalent chromium heavy metal using corn（Zea mays L.）［J］.Cereal Research Communications，2021，49（1）：65‑72.
［26］吴荣，刘善江，孙昊，等.长期化肥配施不同有机肥对土壤和玉米中重金属累积的影响［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2020，26（11）：2010‑2019.
WU R，LIU S J，SUN H，et al.Effects of long‑term chemical fertilizer application with different organic fertilizers on accumulation of heavy metals in soil and maize［J］.Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2020，26（11）：2010‑2019.
［27］刘善江，徐建铭，李国学.高碑店污泥农用肥效及重金属污染防治［J］.华北农学报，1999，14（1）：118‑122.
LIU S J，XU J M，LI G X.Efficiency of sludge manure and control of heavy metal pollution in Gaobeidian area［J］.Acta Agriculturae Boreali‑Sinica，1999，14（1）：118‑122.
［28］冯嘉仪，阮可瑾，苏思宁，等.构树的污泥适应性及养分和重金属吸收累积特征［J］.应用生态学报，2022，33（6）：1629‑1638.
FENG J Y，RUAN K J，SU S N，et al.Adaptability of Broussonetia papyrifera to sewage sludge and its characteristics of nutrient and heavy metal uptake and accumulation［J］.Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2022，33（6）：1629‑1638.
［29］杨鹏.臭氧-电动力处理对生活污泥中重金属在玉米土壤系统中富集转移的影响［D］.杨凌：西北农林科技大学，2018.
YANG P.Effects of ozone‑electrokinetic treatment on enrichment and transfer of heavy metals in domestic sludge in corn soil system［D］.Yangling：Northwest A & F University，2018.
［30］王静.城市污泥堆肥替代化肥施用对土壤-作物养分、重金属含量的影响及生态风险研究［D］.成都：四川农业大学，2022.
WANG J. Effects of sludge compost instead of chemical fertilizer on soil‑crop nutrients and heavy metal content and ecological risk［D］.Chengdu：Sichuan Agricultural University，2022.
［31］武升，张俊森，张杰瑜，等.施用城镇生活污泥对小麦产量和品质及安全性的影响［J］.中国土壤与肥料，2021（3）：324‑330.
WU S，ZHANG J S，ZHANG J Y，et al.Study on the effect of municipal sewage sludge on wheat yield，quality and safety［J］.Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China，2021（3）：324‑330.
［32］王丽霞，杜子文，封莉，等.连续施用城市污泥后林地土壤中重金属的含量变化及生态风险［J］.环境工程学报，2021，15（3）：1092‑1102.
WANG L X，DU Z W，FENG L，et al.Eco‑environmental risk assessment of urban sludge application in forest land［J］.Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2021，15（3）：1092‑1102.
［33］梅晓洁，方宁，颜莹莹，等.我国圩畈地区典型城市生活污泥土地利用潜力分析［J］.给水排水，2023，59（9）：50‑56.
MEI X J，FANG N，YAN Y Y，et al.Potential analysis for the land application of municipal sewage sludge in plain polder area in China［J］.Water & Wastewater Engineering，2023，59（9）：50‑56.
［34］朱琳莹，许修宏，姜虎，等.污泥堆肥对盐碱土土壤环境和作物生长的影响［J］.水土保持学报，2012，26（6）：135‑138.
ZHU L Y，XU X H，JIANG H，et al.Effects of sewage sludge compost on soil environment and crop growth of saline‑alkali soil［J］.Journal of Soil and Water Conservation，2012，26（6）：135‑138.
［35］丁超群，白莉萍，齐洪涛.堆肥污泥施用于杨树后土壤理化性质及土壤污染风险［J］.环境工程学报，2022，16（7）：2381‑2387.
DING C Q，BAI L P，QI H T.Physico‑chemical properties and environmental pollutions in soil amended with composted sewage sludge to poplar［J］.Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2022，16（7）：2381‑2387.
［36］李海洋，孙文彦，彭祚登，等.油松育苗地施用污泥厌氧消化产品重金属污染风险评价［J］.安徽农业科学，2022，50（2）：122‑126.
LI H Y，SUN W Y，PENG Z D，et al.Risk assessment of heavy metal pollution by applying sludge anaerobic digestion products in the nursery field of Pinus tabulaeformis［J］.Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences，2022，50（2）：122‑126.

［37］王美，李书田，马义兵，等.长期不同施肥措施对土壤和作物重金属累积的影响［J］.农业环境科学学报，2014，33（1）：63‑74.
WANG M，LI S T，MA Y B，et al.Effect of long‑term fertilization on heavy metal accumulation in soils and crops［J］.Journal of Agro‑Environment Science，2014，33（1）：63‑74.

［38］蔡尽忠，李火金，邓盈.玉米秸秆与污泥混合热解对生物碳特性及重金属的影响（英文）［J］.农业工程学报，2020，36（6）：239‑245.
CAI J Z，LI H J，DENG Y.Effects of maize stovers and sewage sludge co‑pyrolysis on characteristics and heavy metals in biochar［J］.Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering（Transactions of the CSAE），2020，36（6）：239‑245.

［39］尹晓明，王荣江，徐潇潇，等.猪粪堆肥过程中养分和重金属含量的动态变化［J］.植物营养与肥料学报，2019，25（2）：254‑263.
YIN X M，WANG R J，XU X X，et al.Dynamic changes of nutrient and heavy metal concentrations during swine composting［J］.Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2019，25（2）：254‑263.

[1]	WANG Jinxin, JIA Linguang, SHAO Jianzhu, SUN Jianshe, PENG Jianying. Changes of Carbohydrate Content and C/N in Branches and Leaves during Flower Bud Differentiation of Tianhong 2 Apple [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(7): 124-132.
[2]	LI Dahua, KONG Shu, LI Dong, YU Xiao. Light Weight Detection Algorithm for Apple Surface Defect Based on Improved YOLOv7 [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 53(3): 141-150.
[3]	CHEN Cong, YU Xiao, GONG Qi. Apple Leaf Diseases Identification Based on Improved Residual Network [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(4): 152-161.
[4]	ZHANG Sipu, ZHOU Qianqian, CUI Wei, ZHANG Ke, HAN Lixin, QU Zhenfang, LU Yunfeng, TANG Cunduo, NIU Jiajia. Effects of L‐tert‐leucine on Quality and Storage of Gala Apple [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(12): 172-180.
[5]	WANG Yingchao, ZHANG Jingjing, JIA Donglin, ZHOU Tengfei. Grading of Apple Based on K‑means Clustering and Improved MLP [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2023, 52(1): 161-171.
[6]	YANG Yang, LIU Yuanyuan. Identification and Sequence Analysis of the MdLAC Gene Family Members in Apple [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(7): 125-135.
[7]	NIU Jiajia, ZHANG Sipu, ZHANG Ke, HAN Lixin, QU Zhenfang, MIAO Jianyin. Effects of 5‑Aminolevulinic Acid Treatment on Storage of Fuji Apple during Fruit Expansion Stage [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(10): 146-153.
[8]	TIAN Jia, LI Jia, MENG Qingbo, LI Zhongyong, XU Jizhong. Heat Tolerance Threshold and Physiological and Biochemical Responses of Leaves of Different Apple Varieties [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 50(1): 121-128.
[9]	SHI Yi, LIANG Bowen, HU Junfeng, DONG Yueqi, DU Peihua, LI Zhongyong, ZHANG Xueying, XU Jizhong. Effects of Different Nitrogen Forms and Concentrations on Growth and Nitrogen Absorption,Transportation of Red Fuji Young Apple Trees on Dwarf Rootstock [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 49(9): 112-119.
[10]	GUO Dan, HAN Yingqun, WEI Xin, HAO Yi. Relationship between Quality and Browning Physiological Changes of Fresh-cutting Apples during Cold Storage Period [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 49(8): 173-180.
[11]	HUANG Song, LI Ming, JIAO Jian, SONG Chunhui, WANG Miaomiao, BAI Tuanhui, WANG Hao, FENG Jiancan, ZHENG Xianbo. Effect of Rejuvenating Trunk Buried Combined with IBA Treatment on Apple Cuttings Rooting [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 49(6): 132-136.
[12]	WANG Aibin, XIE Jindou, YAN Shuai, ZHOU Hongyu. Evaluation on Soil Nutrition and Environmental Quality of the Advantageous Ralls Apple Production Area of Huaizhuo Basin [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 49(4): 45-54.
[13]	ZHANG Linyao, MENG Xianglong, WANG Wuke, ＲEN Hongmin, HU Tongle, CAO Keqiang. Ｒesearch on the Field Control Effect of Biocontrol Agent LZ-1 against Apple Ｒing Ｒot on Branches and Trunks [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2019, 48(10): 99-104.
[14]	ZHOU Hanmi, NIU Xiaoli, YAN Hui, ZHAO Long, ZHAO Na, XIANG Youzhen. Effects of Water and Fertilizer Coupling on Growth and Photosynthetic Characteristics of Young Apple Tree [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2019, 48(10): 112-119.