Effects of Tillage Method Combined with Organic Material Application on Yield and Quality of Maize in Chernozem

doi:10.15933/j.cnki.1004-3268.2026.08.002

Abstract

Abstract: A field experiment was conducted from 2024 to 2025 to investigate the effects of tillage methods［no tillage（NT），deep tillage（PT），and rotary tillage（RT）］ combined with organic materials［straw（S），straw plus pig manure （SM），straw plus fulvic acid organic fertilizer（SH），and straw plus microbial organic fertilizer（SW）］on maize plant height，SPAD value，aboveground dry matter accumulation，yield and its components，and grain quality，so as to identify suitable tillage method and organic material for yield stability and quality improvement in the chernozem region.The results showed that，among different tillage methods，PT treatment generally had the highest plant height，aboveground dry matter accumulation at maturity，ear number，kernel number per ear，yield，and grain starch content.Compared with NT treatment，the yield of PT treatment increased by 9.4% and 5.0% in 2024 and 2025，respectively. RT treatment had the highest 100‐grain weight，crude protein content，total amino acid content，lysine content，and leucine content. Among different organic materials，yield showed interannual variation，S treatment had the highest yield in 2024，and SH treatment had the highest yield in 2025；SW treatment had the highest aboveground dry matter accumulation at maturity；SM treatment had the highest starch content；SH treatment had the highest crude protein，crude fat，and total amino acid contents.Among different treatment combinations，PTSW treatment had the highest yield in 2024，reaching 11 576.2 kg/ha，which was 21.3% higher than that of NTN（no tillage and organic material） treatment；in 2025，PTSH treatment had the highest yield，reaching 14 590.2 kg/ha，which was 21.2% higher than that of NTN treatment；PTSM treatment had the highest starch content of 65.08%，which was 2.1% higher than that of NTN treatment；RTS treatment had the highest crude protein content of 8.71%，which was 16.8% higher than that of NTN treatment；RTSH treatment had the highest total amino acid content of 4.14%，which was 18.7% higher than that of NTN treatment.Yield was significantly positively correlated with plant height，100‐grain weight，ear number，kernel number per ear，crude protein content，and aboveground dry matter accumulation. Overall，PT treatment can be considered a suitable tillage method for yield stability and quality improvement of maize in the chernozem region，among organic materials，SH treatment shows balanced overall performance，and PTSH treatment can be recommended as a priority combination for yield stability and quality improvement.

Key words: Maize, Tillage method, Organic material, Yield, Grain quality

摘要： 于2024—2025年开展田间试验，研究耕作方式［免耕（NT）、深翻（PT）、旋耕（RT）］配施有机物料［秸秆（S）、秸秆+猪粪（SM）、秸秆+黄腐酸有机肥（SH）、秸秆+微生物有机肥（SW）］对玉米株高、SPAD值、地上部干物质积累量、产量及其构成因素和籽粒品质的影响，以明确适宜黑钙土区玉米稳产提质的耕作方式和有机物料。结果表明，不同耕作方式间比较，总体上，PT处理株高、完熟期地上部干物质积累量、穗数、穗粒数、产量、籽粒淀粉含量均最高，2024 年和2025 年产量较NT 处理分别提高9.4% 和5.0%；RT处理百粒质量、粗蛋白含量、总氨基酸含量、赖氨酸含量、亮氨酸含量均最高。不同有机物料间比较，产量存在年际间差异，2024年S处理产量最高，2025年SH处理产量最高；SW处理完熟期地上部干物质积累量最高；SM处理淀粉含量最高；SH处理粗蛋白、粗脂肪和总氨基酸含量最高。不同组合间比较，2024年PTSW处理产量最高，为11 576.2 kg/hm^²，较免耕不施有机物料处理（NTN）提高21.3%；2025年PTSH 处理产量最高，为14 590.2 kg/hm^²，较NTN 处理提高21.2%；PTSM 处理淀粉含量最高，为65.08%，较NTN处理提高2.1%；RTS处理粗蛋白含量最高，为8.71%，较NTN处理提高16.8%；RTSH处理总氨基酸含量最高，为4.14%，较NTN处理提高18.7%。产量与株高、百粒质量、穗数、穗粒数、粗蛋白含量和地上部干物质积累量均呈显著正相关。综合来看，PT处理可作为黑钙土区玉米稳产提质的适宜耕作方式，有机物料中SH处理综合表现较均衡，PTSH处理可作为稳产提质的优先推荐组合。

关键词: 玉米, 耕作方式, 有机物料, 产量, 籽粒品质

CLC Number:

S513

Li Peibo, Fan Wei, Li Xiaolin, Zhang Shuimei, Liu Ximing, Zhao Zhenlin, Zhang Chang, Yan Jinyao, Liang Yao, Liang Yunjiang, Cai Hongguang. Effects of Tillage Method Combined with Organic Material Application on Yield and Quality of Maize in Chernozem[J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(8): 10-21.

李培博, 范围, 李晓林, 张水梅, 刘熙明, 赵震琳, 张畅, 闫金垚, 梁尧, 梁运江, 蔡红光. 耕作方式配施有机物料对黑钙土玉米产量和品质的影响[J]. 河南农业科学, 2026, 55(8): 10-21.

Figures/Tables 12

References

［1］李少昆，赵久然，董树亭，等. 中国玉米栽培研究进展与展望［J］. 中国农业科学，2017，50（11）：1941‐1959.

Li S K，Zhao J R，Dong S T，et al. Advances and prospects of maize cultivation in China［J］. Scientia Agricultura Sinica，2017，50（11）：1941‐1959.

［2］中华人民共和国国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴 2024［M］. 北京：中国统计出版社，2024.

National Bureau of Statistics of the People’s Republic of China. China statistical yearbook 2024［M］. Beijing：China Statistics Press，2024.

［3］王立春，王永军，边少锋，等. 吉林省玉米高产高效绿色发展的理论与实践［J］. 吉林农业大学学报，2018，40（4）：383‐392.

Wang L C，Wang Y J，Bian S F，et al. Theory and practice for high yield，high efficiency and green development of maize in Jilin Province［J］. Journal of Jilin Agricultural University，2018，40（4）：383‐392.

［4］高洪军，彭畅，张秀芝，等. 不同秸秆还田模式对黑钙土团聚体特征的影响［J］. 水土保持学报，2019，33（1）：75‐79.

Gao H J，Peng C，Zhang X Z，et al. Effects of different straw returning modes on characteristics of soil aggregates in chernozem soil［J］. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation，2019，33（1）：75‐79.

［5］韩晓增，李娜. 中国东北黑土地研究进展与展望［J］. 地理科学，2018，38（7）：1032‐1041.

Han X Z，Li N. Research progress of black soil in Northeast China［J］. Scientia Geographica Sinica，2018，38（7）：1032‐1041.

［6］王治统，凌俊，刘子熙，等. 秸秆还田方式对土壤理化性质和玉米产量的影响［J］. 中国生态农业学报（中英文），2024，32（4）：663‐674.

Wang Z T，Ling J，Liu Z X，et al. Effect of straw return practices on soil physico‐chemical properties and maize yield［J］. Chinese Journal of Eco‐Agriculture，2024，32 （4）：663‐674.

［7］杨凯，杜延全，张西兴，等. 有机物料与化肥配施提升土壤肥力、养分利用和玉米产量研究［J］. 中国土壤与肥料，2024（4）：76‐82.

Yang K，Du Y Q，Zhang X X，et al. Experimental study on combined application of organic materials and chemical fertilizers to improve soil fertility，nutrient utilization and maize yield［J］. Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China，2024（4）：76‐82.

［8］蒋雨洲，崔馨宇，张燕，等. 配施不同有机物料对玉米养分积累及土壤微生物特征的影响［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2025，31（5）：943‐955.

Jiang Y Z，Cui X Y，Zhang Y，et al. Effects of combined application of organic materials on nutrient accumulation in maize and soil microbial characteristics［J］. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2025，31（5）：943‐955.

［9］Liu S K，Wu B Y，Niu B，et al. Regional suitability assessment for different tillage practices in Northeast China：a machine learning aided meta‐analysis［J］.Soil and Tillage Research，2024，240：106094.

［10］梁尧，蔡红光，闫孝贡，等. 玉米秸秆不同还田方式对黑土肥力特征的影响［J］. 玉米科学，2016，24（6）：107‐113.

Liang Y，Cai H G，Yan X G，et al. Effect of different maize straw‐returning modes on the fertility of black soil［J］. Journal of Maize Sciences，2016，24（6）：107‐113.

［11］张锋. 不同秸秆还田方式对玉米生长发育及耕层土壤性质的影响［D］. 哈尔滨：东北农业大学，2019.

Zhang F. Effects of methods of different straw returning on growth and development of maize and soil properties of tillage layer［D］. Harbin：Northeast Agricultural University，2019.

［12］Simić M，Dragičević V，Mladenović Drinić S，et al. The contribution of soil tillage and nitrogen rate to the quality of maize grain［J］. Agronomy，2020，10（7）：976.

［13］李翔宇，季欣杰，王雪莲，等. 秸秆还田配施氮肥对春玉米产量和籽粒品质的影响［J］. 作物学报，2025，51 （3）：696‐712.

Li X Y，Ji X J，Wang X L，et al. Effects of straw returning combined with nitrogen fertilizer on yield and grain quality of spring maize［J］. Acta Agronomica Sinica，2025，51（3）：696‐712.

［14］Wang L Q，Yu X F，Gao J L，et al. Regulation of tillage on grain matter accumulation in maize［J］. Frontiers in Plant Science，2024，15：1373624.

［15］莫桂梅，张泽坤，贺露露，等. 不同磷水平与水分条件下黄腐酸对旱区土壤磷有效性及玉米生长与磷吸收的调控效应［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2025，31（7）：1366‐1377.

Mo G M，Zhang Z K，He L L，et al. Regulatory effects of fulvic acid on soil phosphorus availability，maize growth， and phosphorus uptake under different phosphorus levels and water conditions in arid regions［J］. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2025，31（7）：1366‐1377.

［16］崔家馨，韩钰，冯晨，等. 秸秆还田配施复合微生物菌剂对退化褐土修复及关键微生物筛选［J］. 河南农业大学学报，2026，60（1）：110‐121.

Cui J X，Han Y，Feng C，et al. Remediation effects and keystone microbial taxa screening in degraded cinnamon soil using straw returning combined with microbial agents［J］. Journal of Henan Agricultural University，2026，60（1）：110‐121.

［17］张银杰，苗玉红，盛开，等. 配施有机肥调控农田土壤磷素有效性研究进展［J］. 河南农业大学学报，2025，59（2）：189‐198.

Zhang Y J，Miao Y H，Sheng K，et al. Research progress on organic fertilizers application regulates phosphorus availability in farmland soil［J］. Journal of Henan Agricultural University，2025，59（2）：189‐198.

［18］甘元炜，冯小杰，李永华，等. 施用微生物肥料对我国玉米产量影响的Meta分析［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2023，29（12）：2247‐2257.

Gan Y W，Feng X J，Li Y H，et al. Effects of microbial fertilizer application on maize yield in China：a meta‐analysis［J］. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2023，29（12）：2247‐2257.

［19］焦帅，王玮瑜，赵兴敏，等. 耕作方式对黑钙土主要肥力特征及玉米产量的影响［J］. 干旱地区农业研究，2020，38（1）：31‐38.
Jiao S，Wang W Y，Zhao X M，et al. Effects of tillage methods on major fertility characteristics of chernozem soil and maize yield［J］. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas，2020，38（1）：31‐38.

［20］徐欣，王笑影，鲍雪莲，等. 长期免耕不同秸秆覆盖量对玉米产量及其稳定性的影响［J］. 应用生态学报，2022，33（3）：671‐676.
Xu X，Wang X Y，Bao X L，et al. Effects of long‐term no‐tillage and stover mulching on maize yield and its stability［J］. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology，2022，33（3）：671‐676.

［21］Alamu E O，Menkir A，Adesokan M，et al. Near‐infrared reflectance spectrophotometry（NIRS） application in the amino acid profiling of quality protein maize（QPM）［J］.Foods，2022，11（18）：2779.

［22］展文洁，刘剑钊，梁尧，等. 不同耕作方式对玉米根系特性及养分吸收转运的影响［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2020，26（5）：817‐825.
Zhan W J，Liu J Z，Liang Y，et al. Effect of soil tillage modes on root morphology and nutrient uptake and translocation of maize［J］. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2020，26（5）：817‐825.

［23］于秀春，孙仲秀，姜荧荧，等. 东北黑土区主要土壤障碍层的研究进展与展望［J］. 土壤，2025，57（3）：498‐509.
Yu X C，Sun Z X，Jiang Y Y，et al. Research progress and prospects on major soil constraint horizons in northeast black soil region of China［J］. Soils，2025，57（3）：498‐509.

［24］Qian Y Q，Zhang Z B，Jiang F H，et al. Impacts of tillage treatments on soil physical properties and maize growth at two sites under different climatic conditions in black soil region of Northeast China［J］. Soil and Tillage Research，2025，248：106471.

［25］蔡红光，梁尧，刘慧涛，等. 东北地区玉米秸秆全量深翻还田耕种技术研究［J］. 玉米科学，2019，27（5）：123‐129.
Cai H G，Liang Y，Liu H T，et al. Research on full maize straw returning with deep ploughing mode in the Northeast China［J］. Journal of Maize Sciences，2019，27（5）：123‐129.

［26］Tong X Y，Liu X F，Wu P T，et al. More frequent precipitation during the maize growth period offsets the yield increasing effect of straw mulching in China：a meta‐analysis［J］. Soil and Tillage Research，2026，256：106870.

［27］Zhang X L，Liu Z M，Shao X W，et al. Deep tillage improves the grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency of maize （Zea mays L. ） under a wide‐narrow row alternative system in Northeast China［J］. International Journal of Plant Production，2022，16（1）：63‐76.

［28］谷思玉，朱玉伟，郭兴军，等. 不同耕作方式下黑土物理性状及其对玉米苗期生长的影响［J］. 华北农学报，2018，33（4）：226‐231.
Gu S Y，Zhu Y W，Guo X J，et al. Effects of different tillage ways on seedling growth of maize and soil physical properties in mollisol region ［J］. Acta Agriculturae Boreali‐Sinica，2018，33（4）：226‐231.

［29］娄菲，左怿平，李萌，等. 有机肥替代部分化肥氮对糯玉米产量、品质及氮素利用的影响［J］. 作物学报，2024，50（4）：1053‐1064.
Lou F，Zuo Y P，Li M，et al. Effects of organic fertilizer substituting chemical fertilizer nitrogen on yield，quality，and nitrogen efficiency of waxy maize［J］. Acta Agronomica Sinica，2024，50（4）：1053‐1064.

［30］裴丽珍，陈远学，张雯雯，等. 有机物料还田对夏玉米穗位叶光合性能及氮代谢的影响［J］. 作物学报，2022，48（8）：2115‐2124.
Pei L Z，Chen Y X，Zhang W W，et al. Effects of organic material returned on photosynthetic performance and nitrogen metabolism of ear leaf in summer maize［J］. Acta Agronomica Sinica，2022，48 （8）：2115‐2124.

［31］Wu G，Ling J，ZhaO D Q，et al. Deep‐injected straw incorporation improves subsoil fertility and crop productivity in a wheat‐maize rotation system in the North China Plain［J］. Field Crops Research，2022，286：108612.

［32］Gao F，Li Z，Du Y，et al. The combined application of urea and fulvic acid solution improved maize carbon and nitrogen metabolism［J］. Agronomy，2022，12（6）：1400.

［33］王利青，刘洪月，于晓芳，等. 耕作方式导致的土壤肥力差异影响玉米籽粒营养物质积累［J］. 植物营养与肥料学报，2024，30（9）：1705‐1717.
Wang L Q，Liu H Y，Yu X F，et al. Soil fertility differences due to tillage methods influence nutrient accumulation in maize grain［J］. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers，2024，30（9）：1705‐1717.

［34］Lu T，Shi J M，Lu Z L，et al. Appropriate application of organic fertilizer enhanced yield，microelement content， and quality of maize grain under a rotation system［J］.Annals of Agricultural Sciences，2024，69（1）：19‐32.

[1]	Wang Wenxia, Shi Tian, Chang Bokai, Du Jie. Mechanisms of Brassinolide in Alleviating Drought Stress in Flax Seedlings [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(8): 54-63.
[2]	Li Fangjie, Shi Dakun, Wei Xiaoyi, Wei Feng, Liu Junheng, Mei Yongxian. Comprehensive Evaluation of Lodging Resistance of 78 Maize Inbred Lines and Screening of Core Indexes [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(7): 11-19.
[3]	Su Hao, Yang Qingfei, Pei Shun, Liu Aiyu, Xie Zhangshu. Effects of Sowing Date and Chemical Topping Date on Population Structure，Photosynthetic Characteristics，and Yield Formation of Summer⁃Sown Short⁃Season Cotton [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(7): 42-51.
[4]	LIU Facai, FU Jiangpeng, YAN Baoqin, ZHAO Zhihui, ZHOU Yingxia, WEI Wei, LI Lili, WANG Yongdong. Comprehensive Evaluation of Adaptability of Different Sorghum Germplasms in Arid Region of Longdong [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(6): 23-30.
[5]	LI Xiujie, WANG Xiuping, ZHANG Xinyou. Nitrogen Response Characteristics of Peanut Varieties with Different Quality Types and Precise Nitrogen Application Recommendation [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(6): 44-55.
[6]	ZHANG Yunhong, YANG Yonghui, HAN Weifeng, HUA Yingpeng, GAO Cuimin, PAN Xiaoying, HE Fang, ZHANG Huan, DING Jinli, XU Qihao, LIU Wen. Effects of Nitrogen Fertilizer Reduction Combined with Different Functional Organic Fertilizers on Soil Nitrogen Transformation，Water and Nitrogen Use，and Yield of Maize [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 1-12.
[7]	ZHANG Meiwei, GUO Hanxiao, MU Weilin, YU Ting, ZHANG Panpan, LI Chuan, YAN Zhenhua, QIAO Jiangfang. Effect of Times of Spraying Chemical Regulator on Canopy and Stem Characteristics of Densely Planted Maize [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 13-21.
[8]	YAN Lili, HONG Yao, LIANG Guili. Effects of Nitrogen Application Method and Rate on Photosynthetic Characters，Antioxidant Properties，and Yield of Maize under High Temperature Stress after Flowering [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 22-34.
[9]	MU Weilin, GUO Hanxiao, YAN Zhenhua, YU Ting, ZHANG Meiwei, ZHANG Panpan, LI Chuan, NIU Jun, QIAO Jiangfang. Effects of Planting Patterns on Agronomic Traits，Grain Filling Characteristics and Yield of Different Summer Maize Varieties [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 35-42.
[10]	LIANG Lu, YIN Kun, ZHANG Weijie, ZHUANG Qiuli, XU Bohan, TIAN Kaiyue, ZHANG Dongjie, ZHANG Donghui, HUANG Yubo. Impact of Vermicompost Application Rate for Winter Wheat on Dry Matter Accumulation，Transportation，and Yield of Subsequent Maize in Lime Concretion Black Soil [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 43-52.
[11]	YANG Junjie, LI Hongchen, ZHANG Xiaoquan, CHANG Jianbo, GUO Jie, XIA Zongliang. Effects of Different Nitrogen Application Rates on Agronomic Traits，Nitrogen Metabolism，Yield，and Quality of the New Flue‐Cured Tobacco Line YM2020 [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 53-62.
[12]	MENG Xiangqi, DONG Yanhong, LI Xulin, HAN Zenghui, ZHANG Shimin, ZHENG Shuyun, LIU Junhao, MA Lei, LI Zengqiang. Effects of Different Organic Materials with Equal Carbon Application on the Yield of Chinese Cabbage and Soil Fertility [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(5): 73-82.
[13]	ZHANG Xiliang, ZHANG Changhui, SHEN Tao, WANG Hanlei, ZHANG Xiaomei, QIU Hongbo, LI Leixin. Screening of Candidate Genes Resistant to Maize Head Smut Based on RNA‑seq and WGCNA [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(4): 10-22.
[14]	MA Xuhui, ZHANG Fuyan, ZHAO Wan, WANG Jiahuan, CHENG Zhongjie, ZHANG Zhongzhou, LI Liulong, DING Jiacun, ZHAO Chi, WANG Hanfeng, CHEN Xiaojie. Analysis of High and Stable Yield Performance and Genetic Characteristics of New Wheat Cultivar Yutong 112 [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(4): 23-32.
[15]	SHI Yuhang, DAI Yaxuan, LI Danping, XING Ye, REN Shaoqi, JIN Shan, LIU Haifeng. Effects of Nitrogen Application Rate and Transplanting Density on Source‑Sink Characteristics of Black Rice in Cool Regions of Northeast China [J]. Journal of Henan Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 55(4): 33-47.